Following a turbulent season that ended in relegation, Carlisle United face a summer of uncertainty, not just in the dugout but also on the pitch — with key players Matt Dennis and Kadeem Harris potentially heading for the exit.
Head coach Mark Hughes, whose own future remains unresolved, confirmed that discussions are likely to take place with Dennis, the club’s top scorer, in the coming weeks. The 23-year-old striker netted six goals in just 14 appearances, having joined mid-season on a short-term deal.
Dennis attracting interest after standout stint
The former MK Dons man made an instant impact at Brunton Park, with his goals ultimately proving a rare bright spark in an otherwise forgettable campaign. Yet with his contract now expired, Carlisle must move quickly if they are to secure his services amid rising competition.
“Matt has done himself no harm whatsoever,” said Hughes. “He came in on a short-term deal, backed his ability and has produced for the most part. I’m sure other clubs will be looking at him… we could have conversations with him and try and convince him that he’s got a part to play.”
Dennis has previously featured in the National League for Southend United and may now need to decide whether to drop back to the fifth tier should Carlisle fail to bounce back with ambition. His eye-catching form, however, could open doors to clubs at higher levels seeking a proven finisher on a free.
He is one of 11 players currently out of contract, with United yet to release their retained list — a delay that leaves supporters in the dark as the rebuilding process begins.
Harris hailed – but likely to move on
Also out of contract is experienced winger Harris, who made 31 appearances and scored three goals. His final outing, a 2-2 draw with Salford City, was marked by a standing ovation as he left the pitch — a gesture many interpreted as a farewell.
Hughes acknowledged the likelihood of Harris playing at a higher level next season, praising the 31-year-old for his professionalism and influence during a challenging campaign. The ex-Cardiff and Sheffield Wednesday player has long been admired for his leadership and work ethic, traits Hughes believes others would do well to emulate.
With the club now preparing for life outside the Football League, the prospect of rebuilding without key figures like Harris and Dennis will be daunting for whoever is tasked with leading the Cumbrians into the 2025/26 season.
Writer’s View
The futures of Dennis and Harris speak volumes about the wider uncertainty at Carlisle United. While Dennis represents youthful potential and future goals, Harris embodies the professionalism and consistency that teams in transition desperately need. Losing both would leave a sizeable void — but if Hughes or his successor can act swiftly, keeping at least one could be the first step in turning Carlisle’s fortunes around.
