| Manager Name | Odds | Bookmaker |
|---|---|---|
| Jack Wilshere | 4/6 | MyriadPlay |
| Tom Cleverley | 2/1 | MyriadPlay |
| Ian Evatt | 5/1 | MyriadPlay |
Odds are correct at the time of writing and are subject to change. Please gamble responsibly. For help with gambling addiction, visit BeGambleAware.org.
The managerial spotlight is shining brightly on Plymouth Argyle as the club searches for a new head coach to lead them into the upcoming campaign. Following the recent departure of Miron Muslic from Home Park, supporters are watching the betting markets closely, hoping for signs of a swift and savvy appointment that can steady the ship and restore momentum.
Argyle’s return to the Championship brought early promise, but managerial instability made consistency hard to find, and relegation followed. The latest search comes in a period of transition, with results, media whispers, and behind-the-scenes interviews all feeding into a volatile market. Betting odds are shifting quickly, with former Premier League names and current EFL bosses featuring prominently.
This isn’t unfamiliar territory for the Pilgrims. In recent years, Plymouth have experienced more than their fair share of managerial turnover, each time triggering a wave of speculation and shifting bookmaker favourites. While these markets aren’t always accurate predictors, they often highlight the frontrunners being genuinely considered behind closed doors.
Who Will Be the Plymouth Argyle Manager?
With the market shifting quickly, three standout candidates have emerged as front-runners for the Plymouth Argyle job—each offering a different direction for the club’s next chapter.
Jack Wilshere (Top Candidate)
Once one of English football’s brightest midfield prospects, Jack Wilshere is now forging a managerial path in the professional game. Currently in charge of Arsenal’s U18s, Wilshere has earned plaudits for his work developing young talent. Though still inexperienced at senior level, his high-profile playing career and grounding in a Premier League academy setup have made him an intriguing option.
Wilshere favours a technical, possession-based style, heavily influenced by his time under Arsène Wenger. At Plymouth Argyle, this could mark a shift toward progressive football, aligning with the club’s modern ambitions.
He’s currently the bookmakers’ favourite at 4/6 with BetVictor, with odds shortening amid reports that he’s been interviewed for the role and is high on the club’s shortlist. “He’s very highly rated by those inside the game,” a Sky Sports pundit noted this week, adding fuel to the speculation.
Tom Cleverley
Tom Cleverley, recently retired from playing, is another young manager making early waves. After hanging up his boots at Watford, he was placed in interim charge late in the 2023/24 season and impressed during his short stint. His understanding of the modern game and reputation for professionalism have helped make him a candidate for permanent roles elsewhere.
Cleverley is known for a compact, disciplined structure on the pitch, favouring midfield control and high work rate. For Plymouth, this could represent a solid foundation after recent instability in the Championship.
He sits second in the betting at 2/1 with BetVictor, with odds holding steady amid whispers that Argyle admire his calm approach and development potential. According to The Athletic, “Cleverley’s quiet authority made an impression during his interim spell at Watford.”
Ian Evatt
Ian Evatt has quietly built a strong reputation in the EFL, having guided Bolton Wanderers back to the Championship with an attacking style and tactical adaptability. A former defender turned manager, Evatt began his managerial career at Barrow before transforming Bolton’s fortunes, winning promotion and keeping them competitive at a higher level.
Evatt’s teams are structured but expressive, with a clear identity based on passing from the back and quick transitions. His experience managing in the division makes him a logical fit for Argyle’s current needs.
At 5/1 with BetVictor, Evatt is an outside contender. While there’s been no formal approach, some journalists suggest he could be tempted if Plymouth commit to a long-term project. Football Insider recently named him “a manager on the radar of several Championship clubs.”
How to Bet on the Plymouth Argyle Manager
Betting on the next Plymouth Argyle manager is straightforward if you follow a few key steps—here’s how to get started with placing your wager on the managerial market.
- Find a Bookmaker: Choose a reputable football betting site that offers odds on the Plymouth Argyle manager market. (Best Football Betting Sites UK 2025 | Footy Bookmakers)
- Locate the Market: Navigate through the site to find the next Plymouth Argyle betting options.
- Select Your Candidate: Choose the manager you believe is most likely to be appointed.
- Add to Bet Slip: Click on your selection to add them to your betting slip.
- Set Your Stake: Enter the amount you wish to wager.
- Confirm Your Bet: Finalise your bet and place it through the bookmaker.
- Monitor Updates: Keep track of odds changes and news to adjust your bets accordingly.
Understanding Managerial Betting Markets
Managerial betting markets typically focus on who will be appointed next, known as the “outright winner” market. Other variations include betting on who will be the first to be sacked or whether a specific manager will take charge within a set timeframe. Odds fluctuate rapidly based on rumours, interviews, and official announcements, making timing and information crucial for punters looking to gain an edge.
Plymouth Argyle Managerial History & Trends
Plymouth Argyle’s managerial history since 2000 paints a picture of occasional stability punctuated by periods of high turnover, particularly during challenging spells in the Championship and League One. While some appointments have brought success and promotion, others have been short-lived experiments that failed to deliver the consistency the club has long craved.
A common thread in Argyle’s hiring pattern is the preference for emerging or progressive managers with a defined philosophy—Steven Schumacher and Ryan Lowe being prime examples. The club tends to favour managers who are tactically astute, often younger, and capable of developing players rather than relying on big-name signings.
However, in recent seasons, the club has been more reactive due to the demands of the Championship. The last three appointments—Foster, Rooney, and Muslic—highlight a period of experimentation as the club looks to re-establish itself in the second tier.
That volatility has translated into fluctuating results and, more recently, relegation.
| Manager | Appointment Date | To | Days in Charge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paul Sturrock | 31/10/2000 | 04/03/2004 | 1,221 |
| Bobby Williamson | 20/04/2004 | 06/09/2005 | 504 |
| Tony Pulis | 23/09/2005 | 14/06/2006 | 264 |
| Ian Holloway | 28/06/2006 | 21/11/2007 | 511 |
| Paul Sturrock | 27/11/2007 | 10/12/2009 | 744 |
| Paul Mariner | 10/12/2009 | 06/05/2010 | 147 |
| Peter Reid | 24/06/2010 | 18/09/2011 | 451 |
| Carl Fletcher | 19/09/2011 | 01/01/2013 | 470 |
| John Sheridan | 06/01/2013 | 28/05/2015 | 873 |
| Derek Adams | 11/06/2015 | 28/04/2019 | 1,417 |
| Ryan Lowe | 05/06/2019 | 07/12/2021 | 916 |
| Steven Schumacher | 07/12/2021 | 19/12/2023 | 742 |
| Ian Foster | 07/01/2024 | 01/04/2024 | 85 |
| Wayne Rooney | 25/05/2024 | 31/12/2024 | 220 |
| Miron Muslic | 05/01/2025 | 28/05/2025 | 143 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Who’s the favourite to be the next Plymouth Argyle manager?
As it stands, Jack Wilshere is the favourite to become the next Plymouth Argyle manager, priced at 4/6 with BetVictor.
Who will be the next manager of Plymouth Argyle?
The next appointment remains uncertain, but current betting suggests Jack Wilshere and Tom Cleverley are serious contenders. Much will depend on Argyle’s ambitions and whether they favour youth or experience
Who would be the best manager for Plymouth Argyle?
That depends on the club’s strategic direction. Wilshere offers fresh ideas and modern football philosophies, while Ian Evatt brings proven EFL managerial experience and stability.
Who is the longest-serving manager at Plymouth Argyle?
Derek Adams is the longest-serving manager in recent history, leading the club for 1,417 days between 2015 and 2019 and achieving promotion from League Two.
Which Plymouth Argyle manager has the best record?
Steven Schumacher holds the best win percentage in recent times, securing a 52.78% win rate and guiding Argyle to the League One title in 2022–23.
How often do Plymouth Argyle change their manager?
Historically, Argyle have changed managers roughly every 1–2 seasons. However, this trend has accelerated in recent years, with five permanent bosses since 2021 alone.