Since the inaugural tournament in 1871, the FA Cup has been the premier domestic cup competition around the world and has produced moments of sheer joy, utter heartbreak and incredible David versus Goliath stories.
From 15 entrants 153 years ago to the extraordinary number of 732 that participated in the 2023-24 edition, the FA Cup has long allowed fans of all clubs to dream. Some dream of winning the competition whereas others simply dream of making the first round.
The competition has faced challenges throughout its long existence, particularly in recent times with those at the very top juggling European competition alongside the three domestic trophies available.
Replays have become synonymous with the competition, with finals even being decided by a second match. Some of the most memorable moments in the competition’s history have been courtesy of a replay. Ronnie Radford’s wonder goal for non-league Hereford United saw them overcome Newcastle United in 1972 and Ryan Giggs’ solo wonder goal in the 1999 semi-final replay are just two of those.
Last week, a decision was made by a select few that will impact the other 700+ competing clubs. Replays from the first round proper onwards have been scrapped, with the FA claiming it will ‘help football at all levels’ as the Premier League is increasing the funding to grassroots football by £33 million.
One man who believes the FA Cup should not be messed with is former Stoke City boss Tony Pulis. During his playing career, Pulis represented clubs in the lower reaches of English football such as Bristol Rovers and Newport County. The Welshman then moved into management, firstly with Division Two side Bournemouth before enjoying spells with Gillingham and Stoke, among others.
He feels that the oldest cup competition in the world didn’t need any changes to the current format.
“There are 92 (league clubs) and non-league clubs from all levels involved in this competition, it’s the greatest cup competition in the world. I think sometimes we mess around with things too much.”
Pulis recalled his childhood and the excitement of waiting for the FA Cup draw to be made and the thrill it brought to everyone, particularly those associated with smaller clubs.
“I honestly believe that for one of the smaller clubs to get one of the big clubs is absolutely extraordinary. The reaction of the supporters, the players who play for those smaller clubs, everybody involved.”
“You sit by that radio, or used to sit by the radio when I was younger, for a third-round draw and just hope and pray that your club would pull one of the big clubs so you could have an opportunity to watch them.”
“Replays were all part and parcel of that, there have been some absolutely outstanding replays played and some that have been real, real shocks and I think that’s what the majority of people in this country want.”
The former Premier League manager went on to express his displeasure at the decision and how it was made.
“Football is dictated by the top clubs now unfortunately and the Premier League are dropping in line with them.”
“I am really disappointed that they’ve done it, especially without consulting other people.”
Tony Pulis was talking to us courtesy of OLBG.
Writer’s View
The bigger picture in this argument is the ease with which a select few clubs have been able to force their opinions into the structure of the greatest domestic cup competition in the world.
The Premier League should make decisions that impact the Premier League, how 20 clubs can make a ruling for a competition that this season alone saw over 700 participants is incredible.
A primary school teacher turned writer, Tom has been part of The Real EFL for two years. He focuses on predictions, deep dives, and insightful content.
